Optimizing for estate versus optimizing for spending
Advice is only meaningful relative to a goal. "This improves your plan" means nothing until someone says what improvement is — and the two candidates pull in different directions often enough to matter.
The two metrics
Crucially, the spending target is held constant between a baseline and any counterfactual. So an estate improvement means "same lifestyle, more left over" and a spending improvement means "more lifetime cash for the same plan shape". Neither is achieved by quietly spending less.
Where they disagree
Deferring CPP raises lifetime guaranteed income and can lower the terminal estate — better on spending, worse on estate. Preserving a TFSA for a tax-free transfer improves the estate and forgoes drawing on it earlier. A meltdown pays tax sooner to leave more later. Each of those is a real trade rather than a free improvement.
This is why the advice engine reports the cross-objective effect alongside the headline one. A recommendation that gains on your active objective and loses on the other is flagged as exactly that, rather than presented as an unambiguous win.
Why there is deliberately no blended score
It would be easy to combine the two into one number with a weighting. It would also be fabricated: the weighting would be invented, and it would produce a precise-looking figure that encodes a value judgement nobody made.
Reporting both and flagging the conflict is less tidy and more honest. The trade-off between leaving money and spending it is not an arithmetic question, and a tool that answers it for you has overstepped.
The same couple, scored two ways
Dan & Marie — 58 and 56, Alberta. Dan retires at 62 with a defined-benefit pension; Marie retires at 60. Their RRSPs are very different sizes, which matters later.
Dan and Marie’s default plan consumes $3,417,836 over its life and leaves $1,784,232. Draw registered money first and the estate rises to $1,976,148 while spending falls to $3,369,510. Defer CPP and OAS to 70 and it goes the other way: spending rises to $3,425,649 and the estate falls to $1,769,711.


Neither change is an improvement until you say which score you mean. (For Priya the benefit ages go the other way — deferring lifts her estate and lowers her spending — which is why the example is the couple’s.)
Choosing yours
A household with dependants, a family business, or a specific bequest in mind has a real estate objective. A household with no dependants, or one whose children are comfortable, usually has a spending objective and has never said so. Most people are somewhere between and lean one way.
It is a five-second setting and it changes what every recommendation in the plan is measured against. Worth five seconds.
A practical note on how the two metrics behave. The estate figure is a single terminal number and therefore sensitive to the horizon you assumed; the spending figure accumulates across every year and is correspondingly steadier. Where the two objectives disagree only slightly, that difference in sensitivity is often the reason — and it is a signal the choice between them does not matter much for your plan.
The objective toggle switches between the two, re-scoring every recommendation and reporting the effect on both — so a change that helps one and hurts the other is visible.
Next: how the advice engine actually measures a recommendation.
GlidePathEngine is an educational planning tool — not financial, investment, tax, or legal advice.