The 4% rule: where it came from, and its limits

The most quoted number in retirement planning came from a single study of American market history, tested a thirty-year horizon, and assumed a spending pattern almost nobody follows. It is genuinely useful, and it is not a rule.

What the research actually asked

The original work tested a narrow question: for a portfolio of US stocks and bonds, what initial withdrawal rate — increased annually with inflation and never adjusted otherwise — would have survived every historical thirty-year period? The answer was close to four percent.

Every one of those is a modelling choice, and each one matters. It was excellent research answering the question it posed. The rule that escaped into common usage is a much broader claim than the research supported.

Where it stops applying to a Canadian retiree

The third point is the sharpest. The rule assumes withdrawals are your choice; the RRIF schedule from episode 21 removes that assumption entirely for the largest account most Canadian retirees own.

The rule against Priya’s actual plan

Priya — 54, Ontario, single. $118,000 salary, $410,000 in her RRSP and $88,000 in her TFSA, planning to retire at 63.

At 4%, Priya’s FI number is $2,950,000 — the portfolio the rule says she would need to replace her income. Her actual plan does not work that way at all.

Her portfolio peaks at $917,791 the year before she retires, so the rule would let her draw $36,712 a year. She spends $58,000. In her first two retired years that is 6.3% of the portfolio. Then CPP, OAS and GIS start at 65 and the draw falls to $28,591, 3.4%. At 72 the RRIF schedule forces 5.4% of her RRSP out whatever she needs.

Against the rule’s 4%, Priya draws 6.3% of her portfolio at 63, 3.4% at 65 once CPP, OAS and GIS start, and 5.4% of her RRSP at 72 because the schedule says so.
The same rate, in three of Priya’s years. None of them is the rule’s.

Each year draws a different rate for a different reason: no guaranteed income yet, then plenty of it, then a schedule she does not control. The rule is answering a question her plan does not pose.

What it is still good for

As a sanity check it is excellent. If your plan implies drawing eight percent of a portfolio for thirty years, something is wrong and the rule tells you instantly. As a sizing shortcut it converts an income need into a rough capital target in one division.

And as a piece of intellectual history it is worth knowing, because the number is quoted constantly by people who have never read what it tested. A projection that models your taxes, your fees, your benefits and your mandatory withdrawals is answering the question the rule was approximating — which is why the two disagree, and why the disagreement is not a problem.

The FIRE calculator applies a withdrawal rate you choose, so you can see the rule’s target alongside what the full projection — with tax, benefits and forced withdrawals — actually says.

Compare the rule to your own plan

Next: reading the cash flow chart — income, tax and spending in one picture.

GlidePathEngine is an educational planning tool — not financial, investment, tax, or legal advice.